Creepy Connie returns with a sidekick, Mackenzie. The two play a cat and mouse game as they vie for Luke’s affection.

Jessie directs a play she’s written and casts Luke as the male lead; the play is a love story, and ‘Creepy Connie’ is the female lead. Meanwhile, Zuri job-shadows Bertram…

Jessie believes Connie, a math tutor she finds for Luke, will be the perfect scholarly influence, not realizing Connie is obsessed with Luke. Connie asks Luke to a Harry Potter…

Hell beckons again when Dean is stricken with a mysterious illness that frightens its sufferers to death. Sam and Dean scramble to find the cause of the disease in time…

Sam, Dean, and Bobby hunt down Lilith and fight her and her demons in a final effort to save Dean’s life.